Vanicream Gentle Body Wash Best Overall
Key details
- Size
- 12 fl oz
- Formula
- Soap-free, pH-balanced
- Fragrance
- Fragrance-free
- Certification
- NEA Seal of Acceptance
Read the back of this bottle and you mostly get a list of what isn't in it: no fragrance, no dye, no lanolin, no sulfate, no soap, no botanical extracts or essential oils. That's the argument. When skin itches after a shower, the cause is usually something the wash stripped out or left behind, and this formula is built to do as little of both as possible.
It's the bottle we reach for when someone's skin stings as they towel off, and it held up to that job through the whole testing period. The lather is honest but thin, nothing like the foam a sulfate wash throws, and it rinses clean without the slippery film heavier creams leave. The National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance is the credential worth pointing at, because it names the condition this wash is aimed at rather than just claiming to be gentle.
Size is the real trade-off. Twelve ounces disappears quickly in a household of daily showers, and you pay more per ounce than for the big pump bottles here; the money goes toward a shorter ingredient list, not more product. The thin lather compounds it, because anyone used to foam uses roughly twice as much as they need. Use your hands rather than a pouf and a bottle goes noticeably further.
There's no scent to argue about, which makes it an easy bottle to share, and it's mild enough to keep at the sink as a hand wash as well. Our advice: buy it for your skin, not for the shower experience, and give it a couple of weeks before deciding the thin lather isn't for you.
Pros
- Leaves out fragrance, soap, sulfates and lanolin
- National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance
- Rinses clean without a slippery film
Cons
- Small 12-ounce bottle and a higher cost per ounce
For skin that itches or stings after a shower, this is the bottle we hand people first: fragrance-free, soap-free and carrying the National Eczema Association seal.