Paula's Choice 2% BHA Exfoliant Best Overall
Key details
- Size
- 4 fl oz
- Format
- Leave-on liquid
- Key Acid
- 2% BHA (salicylic acid)
- Fragrance
- None added
Salicylic acid is the acid that gets into a pore, and 2% is a strength that does the work without stripping the surface. That's the case for this one: in a group where some picks brighten and some resurface, this is the bottle that goes after the blackheads on your nose and the congestion on your chin at the same time. Pores are where it earns its reputation; the smoothing that comes with it is why it stays in a routine.
It's a watery liquid, wet for a few seconds and then dry. We use it at night on clean, dry skin, let it settle, then follow with moisturizer, and a little covers the whole face. Don't expect a spa smell: there's no added fragrance, but the liquid itself has a faint sour note that some noses catch immediately and others never notice.
Where we're careful is the nose. The creases beside the nostrils are thin, and a nightly flood of this can leave them flaking. Keep it off the folds, use a thin layer everywhere else, and you get the benefit without the peeling. On dry skin it can also leave you feeling tight an hour later, which is a moisturizer problem rather than a reason to stop.
Against PanOxyl, our other BHA pick, this costs more ounce for ounce and buys you a formula that's been around long enough to behave predictably on most skin types. That predictability is the reason it sits first. If you've never used an acid and want the safest first step, this is the one we point to.
Pros
- Clears congested pores and blackheads
- Fragrance-free, fast-absorbing liquid
- Gentle enough for nightly use on most skin
Cons
- Costs more ounce for ounce than our other BHA
- Can feel tight without a moisturizer
If you want one exfoliator that handles clogged pores and dull texture without a learning curve, this is the bottle we hand people first.