NYX Highlight & Contour Pro Palette Best Overall
Key details
- Shades
- 8
- Formula
- Pressed powder
- Refillable Pans
- Yes
Eight pans, and each one lifts out. That is what put this palette at the top of our list: the shade you hit first can be replaced on its own, so a good kit does not get thrown away half-full because the contour ran out. It is also the only kit here you can rebuild shade by shade as your skin shifts through the year, and most palettes at this level are sealed for life.
The shades cover real ground: deep tones for the hollow under the cheekbone and along the jaw, mid tones for a lighter wash, and highlighters for the tops of the cheekbones and the bridge of the nose. We tested the build-up rather than the first swipe, and the deeper shades arrive gradually, which is the difference between a shadow you can shape and a stripe you have to rescue.
Two things we noticed. The lightest pan carries shimmer, which we like for an evening and skip for a workday, and blending takes more work than it does with the Black Radiance creams here: a light hand and a clean brush get you there, heavy buffing does not.
Where it wins is the long game. Eight shades, refillable pans, and a slim compact that closes flat mean one purchase keeps covering sculpting, bronzing, and setting, and the pan you empty is the only one you replace. Eight pans you can top up individually is a better arrangement than four you cannot.
Pros
- Eight refillable pans, replaceable one at a time
- Deep shades build gradually instead of landing in a stripe
- One compact covers sculpting, bronzing, and setting
- Slim, flat-closing compact for a makeup bag
Cons
- Undertones lean warm rather than grey
- Hinge feels flimsy on a daily-use compact
Our pick for most people: eight refillable shades that sculpt, bronze, and set, with a finish that reads natural rather than painted.