NYX Butter Gloss Best Overall
Key details
- Shade
- Sugar Glass (clear)
- Finish
- Soft buttery shine
- Formula
- Creamy, non-sticky
- Coverage
- Sheer to medium
Sugar Glass is the clear one in a line known for its buttery texture, and clear turns out to be the hardest-working gloss you can own. It goes over a bare balm, over a matte lipstick that needs reviving, and over a lip liner you've slightly over-drawn, with no pigment to fight your undertone. That's why we kept reaching for this tube even while testing a stack of colored ones.
The texture is what earns it the top spot. Butter Gloss feels like a soft balm going on and never sets into the tacky film that makes you peel your lips apart mid-sentence; a couple of hours in, our lips felt conditioned rather than tight. The shine is a soft, lit-from-within sheen rather than a wet mirror, which is the one place another pick does better — Kiko's 3D Hydra is the mirror-finish option here.
What you give up is wear. A clear gloss sits on the surface, and this one surrenders to a coffee cup faster than the tinted tubes did; we reapplied more with this one than with any other pick. That's the trade for a texture this comfortable, and it's a fair one. The line runs well past clear, too — nudes, pinks, and reds share the same formula, so it's a range rather than a single tube.
Pros
- Buttery texture that never turns tacky
- Clear shade layers over balm, liner, or lipstick
- Leaves lips soft rather than tight
- Small tube that fits a pocket
Cons
- Fades quickly after eating or drinking
This is the gloss we tell people to buy first: clear, buttery, layers over anything, and never turns tacky.