Neutrogena Micellar Wipes 2-Pack Best Overall
Key details
- Cloth
- 100% plant-based
- Count
- 2 packs of 25
- Formula
- Micellar, hyaluronic acid
- Fragrance
- Fragrance-free
Two 25-count packs are what make these the pair we reach for first: one can live on the bathroom shelf, the other in a travel kit. The wipe is a 100% plant-based cloth soaked with micellar water, hyaluronic acid, and a triple emollient blend, and the formula is fragrance-free. That combination sounds busy, but in use it feels like a straightforward makeup wipe that happens to be soft on skin.
We tested these on a full face of foundation and powder and on waterproof mascara. The cloth has enough texture to grip makeup without dragging, and the micellar formula broke down eye makeup with a short hold rather than a scrub. We did not need to rinse, and skin felt clean rather than tight afterward. The resealable flap is the detail that matters over a 25-count pack: press it flat and the remaining wipes stay usable.
We also appreciated that the wipe does not leave a heavy film. Some makeup wipes feel as if they have swapped makeup for lotion; these leave a soft finish that works fine before a serum or moisturizer. The cloth held together in our testing, including around the lash line, which is not always a given with plant-based wipes.
The trade-off is the pack size. A two-pack is great for a bathroom and a travel bag, less so for a clutch or a desk drawer. We kept one pack at home and one in a toiletry case, which is the most sensible way to use it. For most people, that is a small adjustment for a wipe that handles waterproof eye makeup without a fight.
Pros
- Lifts waterproof eye makeup with little rubbing
- Two resealable 25-count packs
- Soft 100% plant-based cloth
- Fragrance-free, no heavy residue
Cons
- Not the cheapest per wipe here
We recommend these as the default because they lift waterproof eye makeup without much rubbing, and the two resealable packs make them easy to keep at home and in a bag.