e.l.f. Matte Magic Mist & Set Best Overall
Key details
- Size
- 2 fl oz
- Finish
- Matte
- Skin Types
- All, especially oily
- Key Ingredients
- Vitamins B and E, burdock root
Shine control is the whole job, and this is the bottle here that does it without leaving a chalky residue behind. The finish is a soft matte — shine down, skin still looking like skin — and it sets cream blush and loose powder in the same pass without grabbing either. What settled it against the pricier picks is consistency: hold, shine control, and value all land in the same place, with no complaint big enough to work around.
That evenness comes partly from a genuinely fine mist. Held at arm's length it lays a light, even layer, which is exactly what keeps a mattifying spray from turning into a wet patch you then have to blend out. The formula also carries vitamin E and burdock root, and while no setting spray is a moisturizer, we noticed the difference — our skin didn't have the tight, pulled feeling a hard matte spray leaves after an hour.
Spray it heavily, though, and it takes a while to dry, and a third pass leaves skin feeling tight rather than set; one or two passes from arm's length is plenty. The bottle is on the smaller side, so a morning-and-lunchtime habit means replacing it more often than the Maybelline or the Rimmel. Day to day we finish less shiny with this than with the NYX or the Maybelline, and that's the whole point of owning one.
Pros
- Soft matte that leaves skin looking like skin
- Fine, even mist that doesn't wet the face
- Shine control and value land together
- Doesn't leave skin feeling tight
Cons
- 2-ounce bottle runs out faster than the larger picks
We recommend the e.l.f. Matte Magic Mist & Set as the safest default here: it knocks back shine, dries down clean, and doesn't change the finish of your foundation to do it.