Armaf Club de Nuit Intense Man Best Overall
Key details
- Size
- 3.6 Fl Oz
- Top Notes
- Bergamot, Lemon, Pineapple, Black Currant
- Closest To
- Creed Aventus
- Concentration
- Eau de Toilette
The bottle people mean when they say they want an Aventus alternative is this one. Club de Nuit Intense Man has built its reputation on getting close to Creed's smoky pineapple for a fraction of the price, and after wearing it alongside the rest of this set, we think it is the closest thing here to a finished, designer-smelling fragrance. Nothing about it reads like a shortcut. The opening is loud, a bright and nearly sharp burst of pineapple and lemon, but give it ten minutes and it settles into the birch-and-vanilla accord people are actually chasing.
Wear time is what keeps that reputation going. It holds through a working day on most skin, and like most cheaper bottles it clings to fabric longer than it does to skin, so a spray on the inside of a jacket carries you into the evening after the skin scent has faded. Under the smoke there is vanilla and amber doing the heavy lifting, and the dry-down is the best part, which is unusual at this price, where the top notes are usually as good as it gets.
Two or three sprays is the ceiling. Past that the opening fills a room before it softens and the pineapple turns syrupy rather than bright. It is also the bottle in this set that draws the most comments, which is a strange thing to be able to say about the cheapest one.
The other thing a budget bottle has to get right is the cost of using it. This is one you can spray on a Tuesday morning without doing arithmetic first, and that changes how often it actually comes off the shelf. The sweet scents in this roundup need an occasion. This one doesn't.
Pros
- Closest to a designer scent of anything here
- Holds through a full working day
- Most adaptable of the men's picks
- Least expensive bottle in this roundup
Cons
- Atomizer can fail before the bottle is empty
We recommend this one first for anyone who wants a single bottle to cover work, weekends and nights out without spending much.