Aquaphor Healing Ointment Best Overall
Key details
- Size
- 14 oz
- Scent
- Unscented
- Made Without
- Dyes, fragrance, preservatives
- Active Ingredient
- Petrolatum 41%
Forty-one percent petrolatum, no water, and nothing added for scent — that combination is the whole case for Aquaphor as a slugging balm. An ointment this occlusive does not add moisture; it slows the water already in your skin from escaping overnight, which is the job description. Everything else in the formula exists to keep that barrier comfortable on compromised skin rather than merely greasy.
In use it is a thick, slightly tacky paste that spreads much further than it looks. A pea-sized amount covers a whole face, so the 14-ounce tub lasts a winter of nightly slugging with plenty left over for the parts of you that are not your face. We put it on cuticles, heels, the corners of a nose raw from a cold, and a flaky patch on an elbow, and it never stung.
What settles it against the rest of this list is range. CeraVe adds ceramides and hyaluronic acid, plain Vaseline adds nothing at all, and Aquaphor sits between them with a formula built for skin that is already windburned, cracked, or peeling. It is also the largest tub here, which matters when you are sealing more than a face.
Nothing about it is elegant. This is a pharmacy paste in a pharmacy tub, and the scent is unscented in the flat, clinical sense rather than the pleasant one. We have stopped expecting elegance from the step that does the most work.
Pros
- Water-free 41% petrolatum barrier that stays put all night
- Fragrance-, dye-, and preservative-free
- Largest tub in this set at 14 ounces
- Works on face, cuticles, heels, and compromised skin
Cons
- Greasy enough to mark bedding if applied heavily
- Requires fingers in the tub
Our top pick because 41% petrolatum seals without extras and the big tub handles face, hands, and heels — the safest first buy for anyone new to slugging.