O'Keeffe's Working Hands Best Overall
Key details
- Size
- 3.4 oz
- Scent
- Unscented
- Format
- Jar
- Key Ingredient
- Glycerin
Working Hands doesn't behave like a lotion. It's a stiff, opaque paste in a squat jar, and you scrape up a pea-sized amount rather than squeezing out a ribbon. That density is the whole idea: this is the cream for hands that are past dry, the split at the tip of a thumb and the knuckles that sting in hot water, and it's the first one we reach for when that's the situation.
The formula is glycerin-heavy and built to sit on the surface as a protective layer rather than vanish into it. It's unscented, hypoallergenic, and labeled as safe for people with diabetes. Apply it after washing, after bathing, and at bedtime, which is good advice for any concentrated cream and especially this one, since sealing damp skin does more than adding another coat to dry skin.
The thing to know before you buy is that this cream can sting. On intact dry skin it's fine; on cracks that are actually open, the first application bites for a few seconds. Use it at bedtime rather than before you leave the house and you'll have forgotten about it before you're asleep.
Of everything here, it's the only one aimed squarely at repair rather than upkeep, and that's what earns it the top spot for this particular problem. Buy the jar rather than a tube where you can: the wide mouth lets you get the last of it out with a fingernail, and there's a surprising amount left at the bottom when it looks finished.
Pros
- Concentrated enough for split, cracked skin
- Unscented and hypoallergenic
- A pea-sized amount covers both hands
- Protective layer hangs on between washes
Cons
- Tacky finish takes a few minutes to settle
- Jar is awkward to carry in a bag
If your hands crack and split rather than just feel dry, this is the one we tell people to buy first.