O'Keeffe's Working Hands Best Overall
Key details
- Size
- 3.4 oz jar
- Scent
- Unscented
- Formula
- Concentrated cream, glycerin
- Skin Type
- Dry to extremely dry
Most creams on this list are trying to sink in. O'Keeffe's Working Hands is trying to stay. It comes out of the jar closer to a paste than a lotion — thick, slightly waxy, built to sit on the surface and hold moisture there instead of vanishing in half a minute. On knuckles that had split and fingertips that caught on wool, that's exactly what we wanted: something with enough body to still be there in the morning.
Two things put it at the top of this list. The first is repair. Cracks that had been open through a week of cold commuting stopped stinging within a few nights, and the rough patch at the base of our thumbs smoothed out well before the jar was a quarter gone. The second is restraint: it's unscented, the label describes it as hypoallergenic and suitable for people with diabetes, and it doesn't collide with a scented soap or a perfume. A pea-sized amount covers both hands, so the 3.4-ounce jar goes further than its size suggests.
The trade is texture. Your hands feel tacky for the first few minutes, which is noticeable if you go straight back to a keyboard. We solved it by moving the jar to the bedside table and making it the last thing before sleep, where the film does the most good anyway. If you need something you can rub in at a desk and forget about, the Gold Bond below is the better fit; if your hands are past the point of ordinary lotion, start here.
Pros
- Repairs split, cracked hands quickly
- Unscented and hypoallergenic
- A little covers both hands
Cons
- Jar format stays home; a tube travels better
- Can sting on cracked or sensitive skin
This is the cream we hand people with split, cracked knuckles: unscented, hypoallergenic, and concentrated enough that one jar lasts a winter.